It doesn't stop there.
Buried inside Wendy's brutal second quarter earnings call last week was a mention that 289 US locations closed during the first half of the year.
There are about 5,700 Wendy's in the US.
"Understand that the health of franchisees certainly is pressured right now because of the sales declines that we have had," Wright told analysts on the call. "You guys know this business. When you see some of the sales declines, it is going to show up in restaurant profitability. It is going to pressure the franchisees and create a little bit of fragility there. When it came to closures, I think what you heard in some previous quarters was closures addressed more as a program for the system. You will see us take a much more targeted approach. We are going to come alongside our franchisees if they need our help."
Thanks, Bob, for the deep analysis. The reality looks to be that this brand will continue to shrink while other fast food chains grow. Not a recipe for success.
Bernstein analyst Danilo Gargiulo said, "We think investors are likely to stay on the sidelines until the next update provides a quantified plan, even as the leadership and capital allocation overhangs we have flagged over the past year are now more constructively addressed. We view the dividend cut as a more deliberate decision to free up capital for investments rather than a distress signal. However, net leverage at 5.0x, the top of the company's target range, still constrains the pace at which management can deploy capital toward the turnaround, and with FY26 guidance withdrawn, investors have no financial framework to hold the plan accountable to until the next quarterly update. We reduce our estimates to account for the flow-through in the model from 2Q."
If Peltz is thinking he could drive a Starbucks-like (SBUX) turnaround at a privately held Wendy's, he may be out of his mind. When was the last time the 84-year-old billionaire actually had his driver take him through a Wendy's drive-through?
Wendy's and Starbucks are totally different food brands that live in totally different places in consumers' minds.
The list
Here are my 20 reasons why Wendy's may be doomed, run through the lens of a consumer who knows a thing or two about business. Moreover, I would argue none of these are easily fixable — and that's a problem for a business with a far-from-pristine balance sheet: Wendy's ended the second quarter with $2.7 billion in long-term debt compared to $341 million in cash.